Symmetric Encryption vs. Asymmetric Encryption: Which to Use and When

Quick Answer: Symmetric encryption uses a single key for both encryption and decryption, making it fast, but it requires secure key sharing. Asymmetric encryption uses public and private key pairs, offering more security features but runs slower. Each type works best for different scenarios - symmetric for bulk data encryption and asymmetric for secure key exchange and digital signatures.

Data encryption is an essential part of cybersecurity. It is used to protect everything from text messages to banking transactions. However, there are different encryption methods available, so you need to know how to choose the right one for specific jobs. 

If you’ve ever been curious about these encryption methods, you’re in luck. We break down both encryption types and explain exactly when to use each one so that you understand when and how they are used.

What is Symmetric Encryption?

Symmetric encryption keeps things simple - one key handles both encryption and decryption. Message-sending applications are a good example of apps that use this type of encryption. If you're using symmetric encryption, both the sender and the receiver need the exact same key. You use it to lock (encrypt) the message, and they use it to unlock (decrypt) it on the other end.

Popular Symmetric Algorithms

AES (Advanced Encryption Standard) is one of the most used symmetric encryption methods. The NSA trusts it for top-secret information, and it powers much of the encryption you use every day. Some common symmetric algorithms are:

• AES-256: Banking-grade encryption that balances speed and security. It is so widely used that most modern processors include special instructions to make AES run faster

• 3DES (Triple DES): An older standard still used in some legacy systems, though it's being phased out

• ChaCha20: A newer algorithm that is very efficient and performs well on mobile devices, where battery life matters

Speed and Performance

When you think about Symmetric encryption, think speed. Generally speaking, most symmetric encryption operations take microseconds, which is very fast when compared to asymmetric encryption, which can take milliseconds. It doesn’t sound like much of a difference, but when you scale up batches of millions of encryption and decryption cycles, it starts making a huge difference. 

This speed advantage makes symmetric encryption perfect for:

• Encrypting large files or databases

• Securing real-time video streams

• Protecting instant messages

• Processing credit card transactions

The main issue is getting that secret key to everyone who needs it without letting anyone else see it. This "key distribution problem" is why you normally see symmetric encryption paired with other security methods to keep keys safe from prying eyes.

What is Asymmetric Encryption?

Asymmetric encryption differs from symmetric encryption in several ways, the most obvious being that it uses two different keys. It has a public key for encryption and a private key for decryption. Your public key is like your email address—you can share it with anyone. Your private key is more like your password to access that email account, which you never share with anyone.

How the Keys Work Together

The real security magic is how these keys are paired together. When data is encrypted with the public key, it can only be decrypted with its matching private key. This setup creates some useful security options:

• Send encrypted messages to someone by using their public key - only they can read it with their private key

• Sign documents digitally with your private key - others verify it's really from you using your public key to decrypt the hash of the original message

• Set up secure connections without having to share secret keys first

Common Asymmetric Algorithms

Several battle-tested algorithms handle asymmetric encryption tasks:

• RSA: The most widely used asymmetric algorithm. Great for encrypting small chunks of data and creating digital signatures

• ECC (Elliptic Curve Cryptography): Newer than RSA, offers similar security with shorter key lengths - perfect for mobile devices and IoT

• Diffie-Hellman: It is not exactly encryption, but it uses asymmetric math to help two parties create a shared secret key

Performance Trade-offs

Better security comes at a cost, and in this case, the cost is speed. Asymmetric encryption runs slower than symmetric - sometimes hundreds or thousands of times slower, depending on the configuration of the encryption. A single RSA operation might take several milliseconds, but when scaled over thousands of operations, it adds up when you're processing lots of data.

It is mainly for this reason that you hardly ever see asymmetric encryption used on its own for large amounts of data. Instead, it is really good at:

• Encrypting small pieces of data like passwords or keys

• Setting up secure connections

• Creating digital signatures

• Sharing symmetric keys securely

How do Symmetric and Asymmetric Encryption Compare?

Now that we've explored the differences let's see how each type of encryption compares to each other. 

Performance and Efficiency

We’ve already seen how symmetric encryption runs a lot faster than asymmetric, but here are some more specifics that will help you understand how much faster it actually is:

• Symmetric encryption processes data roughly 1000x faster.

• A 256-bit AES key handles gigabytes of data per second on standard hardware.

• RSA with a 2048-bit key struggles with more than a few kilobytes per second. 

These speed differences will guide you on how you use each type of encryption in practice:

• For large file transfers, symmetric encryption gets the job done quickly. 

• Secure connection configurations start with asymmetric to exchange keys, then switch to symmetric for the actual data. 

• Battery-powered devices benefit from symmetric encryption because they use less power. 

Security Features

Both encryption types have their own security advantages, but they work well together to make up for their shortfalls:

Symmetric Encryption:

• Easy to implement - with fewer things that can go wrong

• Stronger security per bit of key length

• Less complex math means faster processing times

Asymmetric Encryption:

• No need to share secret keys

• Supports digital signatures

• Perfect for identity verification

• Keys can be revoked if they are compromised

Key Management

Managing keys looks very different between these systems, which makes sense because of the way that they work:

Symmetric Key Management:

• Each pair of users needs a unique shared key

• 100 users means managing 4,950 different keys

• Keys must be transmitted securely

• Changing a key means updating it everywhere, which is not ideal

Asymmetric Key Management:

• Each user just needs one key pair

• 100 users means managing 200 keys in total

• Public keys can be shared openly

• Revoking a compromised key is straightforward

When to Use Symmetric Encryption

Speed makes symmetric encryption the go-to choice for most everyday encryption tasks. Key sharing can be tricky, but it isn’t impossible to overcome. Once you've solved that problem, symmetric encryption handles large amounts of data efficiently without bogging down your systems.

Bulk Data Encryption

Every time you unlock your phone or laptop, symmetric encryption gets to work behind the scenes. Your device decrypts data so fast you don't even notice it happening. This speed makes symmetric encryption perfect for handling large amounts of data, like:

• File system encryption: Protecting data at rest

• Database encryption: Securing sensitive records

• Backup encryption: Keeping archived data safe

• Stream encryption: Protecting real-time video or audio

Communication Between Trusted Parties

Most secure internal communication relies on symmetric encryption. A good example would be a company's internal network. Once you've set up secure key sharing between systems, symmetric encryption keeps data flowing quickly and securely. This approach works well for:

• Internal network traffic between departments

• Communication between data centers

• Secure messaging between team members

• VPN connections after initial setup

Resource-Constrained Environments

Battery life and processing power are scarce resources on mobile devices and IoT sensors. Symmetric encryption uses much less processing power than asymmetric encryption, which makes it the best choice when resources are limited. This power-efficient feature is great for:

• Mobile applications that process sensitive data

• IoT devices that send encrypted sensor readings

• High-throughput web services that handle millions of requests

• Gaming servers that encrypt real-time player data

Real-World Examples

Banking apps are where symmetric encryption is arguably at its best. When you check your balance or make a transfer, the app needs to encrypt and decrypt data instantly without delay. A typical banking app uses symmetric encryption for:

• PIN codes and password verification

• Transaction data during processing

• Account balances in databases

• Session data while you're logged in

When to Use Asymmetric Encryption

Asymmetric encryption solves one of the biggest problems in cryptography - how do you share secrets without having a pre-shared secret first? It runs slower than symmetric encryption but can handle key exchanges and verify identities, which makes it a must-have for modern security requirements.

Key Exchange

Setting up secure connections over insecure networks used to be nearly impossible. Thanks to advancements in hardware and software,  asymmetric encryption was able to change that completely. Now you can visit secure websites, set up VPNs, or create encrypted chat sessions without worrying about someone intercepting your data or encryption keys. This allows:

• HTTPS connections to secure websites

• Initial VPN tunnel establishment

• Secure chat session setup

• Safe symmetric key sharing

Identity Verification

Digital signatures have overhauled how we verify electronic documents and software. Using asymmetric encryption lets you prove that a specific person or organization created or approved something. This verification works for:

• Legal documents requiring signatures

• Software updates from trusted vendors

• Secure email communications

• Website identity verification through SSL/TLS

When to Combine Symmetric and Asymmetric Encryption

Most encryption systems don't choose between symmetric and asymmetric encryption—they use both. This hybrid approach combines the speed of symmetric encryption with the secure key exchange of asymmetric encryption. 

How Hybrid Encryption Works

When you visit a banking website, your browser needs to create a secure connection with the bank's server. Instead of using just symmetric or asymmetric encryption, it uses both in a careful sequence.

First, asymmetric encryption helps your browser and the server agree on a temporary symmetric key without anyone else being able to intercept it. Then, that symmetric key encrypts all the actual data - your login details, account information, and transactions. This process happens in milliseconds, and you probably never notice it unless your internet connection is very slow.

Common Hybrid Systems

SSL/TLS should sound familiar to you; it secures most website traffic today. It is probably one of the best examples of hybrid encryption in the real world. When you see that padlock icon in your browser, these steps are all working as expected:

• The website sends its public key through its SSL certificate

• Your browser creates a random symmetric key

• The symmetric key gets encrypted with the website's public key

• Only the website can decrypt it using its private key

• All further communication uses the faster symmetric encryption

A similar process is used in many other systems like:

• VPN connections

• Secure messaging apps

• Email encryption

• Software update systems

Benefits of the Hybrid Approach

When you combine both encryption types, it solves problems that neither could handle alone. The hybrid approach gives you:

• Fast performance for large amounts of data

• Secure key exchange over unsafe networks

• Strong identity verification when needed

• Better use of system resources

Implementation Challenges

Setting up hybrid encryption for yourself takes careful planning. Although several vendors make this process less complicated, key management becomes more complex because you're juggling both types of keys. You'll need to think about:

• Certificate management for asymmetric keys

• Secure storage for all encryption keys

• Key rotation schedules

• Backup and recovery procedures

Challenges and Considerations

There’s more to setting up encryption than just picking algorithms and generating keys. Successfully implementing encryption requires that you understand the trade-offs of each type of encryption.

Performance Impact

Processing power matters when rolling out encryption. Running heavy encryption on underpowered hardware leads to slow applications and frustrated users (which is never fun to deal with). Think about:

Processing Requirements:

• Symmetric encryption runs well on most hardware.

• Asymmetric operations need beefier processors.

• Mobile devices suffer more from processor-intensive encryption.

• Cloud services might need extra CPU allocation for encryption tasks, which will incur additional costs over time. 

Memory Usage:

• Short term key storage takes up RAM.

• Multiple simultaneous connections also take up RAM.

• SSL/TLS sessions consume extra memory per connection.

• Large key sizes use more memory.

Key Management Headaches

Keys make or break the security of your encryption system. Lose a key, and you lose access to data. Let a key leak, and your security is in question. Managing keys properly takes planning and solid execution.

Storage Security:

• Use Hardware Security Modules (HSMs) to protect important keys.

• Encrypted databases store less sensitive keys.

• Backup copies need their own security.

• Key storage must meet compliance requirements.

Key Rotation:

• Regular key changes limit damage from breaches.

• Old data needs old keys for access.

• Every key change risks data loss.

• Applications must handle key changes smoothly.

Compliance Requirements

Different industries have different compliance regulations related to encryption. Healthcare organizations follow HIPAA guidelines and payment processors deal with PCI-DSS requirements. Government contractors might need FIPS validation. Each standard adds its own complications:

• Specific key lengths

• Approved algorithms only

• Scheduled security audits

• Detailed documentation requirements

Getting Started Right

Starting small helps avoid major problems later. Begin with:

• Test environments to practice key management

• Small pilot projects to find issues

• Clear documentation of all procedures

• Auditing

• Training for everyone handling encrypted data

Conclusion

Picking the right encryption setup can make a huge difference in how well your systems perform and how secure they remain. Symmetric encryption handles bulk data quickly, while asymmetric encryption solves key exchange and identity verification. You'll usually want both, but not always.

Start by looking at what you need to protect. Large amounts of data usually point toward symmetric encryption for better performance. If you need to verify identities or exchange keys securely, then asymmetric encryption is your answer. For most production systems, you'll want a hybrid approach that uses both types.

Remember that encryption is just one piece of your security setup. Keys need protection, systems need monitoring, and staff need training. Properly planning your encryption strategy will prevent the headaches that come from rushed implementations.

Want to try a CBT Nuggets course? Get a free 7-day trial.